Then we knocked each one over to see how much, if any, liquid seeped out. Since 2019, I’ve been analyzing, reviewing, and generally obsessing over products here at Wirecutter, where I’ve written about everything from label makers to solar-eclipse-viewing gear. Most pertinently, I’ve written about insulated wine tumblers, and I spent quite a bit of time testing the buzzy Stanley tumbler against 40-ounce dupes that line store shelves. Most insulated tumblers—whether palm-sized or gigantic—are made from the same materials. And they function in similar ways, which gave me a leg up when I started my research for this guide.
Though the tumbler and lid are both dishwasher-safe, the one-piece lid has crannies where grime and gunk can build up. Deep cleaning this lid is not impossible, but it takes effort, attention to detail, and a straw-cleaning brush (to scrub the interior of the straw). Airplanes, trains, and other modes of public transportation are not known for cleanliness, and you may prefer not to have your tumbler’s straw exposed at all times. The IceFlow tumbler’s straw folds out of sight—and away from germs and dirt—when you’re not using it.
The lid screws into the mouth of the tumbler, and the flip straw folds closed, to create an airtight seal that keeps liquid from seeping out. We tossed this tumbler in a gym tote and purse, and it never leaked and soaked our things. To assess lid quality, we filled each tumbler with water and affixed its lid in place, sealing the sipping port with the lid’s mouthpiece, where applicable.
I then cut around the design so I could save as much of the vinyl scrap for future use as possible. I created the design using PicMonkey and the Cricut Design Space and cut it out using my Cricut Explore. I was sent my Explore for free (love my job!) but I paid for the vinyl out of my own pocket. Elissa Sanci is a senior staff writer for Wirecutter’s discovery team based in Denver. Her byline has appeared in The New York Times, Woman’s Day, Marie Claire, ozark trail chair and Good Housekeeping.
This brand is made with the same type of 18/8 food grade stainless steel as the Yeti, RTIC tumbler and Ozark Trail. I imagine this is because of the vacuum seal; however, the directions for the Yeti tumblers say they can be put in the dishwasher, including the lid. Ozark Trail and Yeti tumblers are made with stainless steel which is easy to clean. These lids are designed to sip out of, not to use with a disposable or reusable straw. The one thing the Yeti really has over the Ozark Trail mug, in terms of performance, is the slider on the lid.
But the Takeya tumbler isn’t dishwasher-safe, and the one-piece lid has too many crevices where dirt and other grime can accumulate. Also, stock is currently very limited, so we’ve reached out to Takeya to confirm whether this model is being updated. But the lid created a weak seal, and it leaked a substantial amount when we knocked the tumbler over. The 24-ounce Corkcicle Cold Cup has flat, easy-to-grip panels along its sides. But the press-in lid doesn’t create a tight enough seal to prevent leakage when the cup is knocked over.
This vessel is the most affordable of our picks, and it’s the only tumbler that comes with two different lids—a straw lid and a flip-top lid (at no additional charge). I’ll be totally honest, I was not expecting this cooler to be as nice as it was. It’s easy to get caught up in brand perception and often times very difficult to break away from what you think you know about a brand. I used the word “think” intentionally, because what I thought I knew about Ozark Trail was not correct. Ozark Trail is proving to be a really solid competitor for outdoor products. This cooler has a number of features that you would find on more expensive coolers and a few that you won’t find.
The Yeti Rambler held 27 ounces of ice for 11 hours and 10 minutes. All three tumblers were filled with the same amount of crushed ice. The amount decided upon was 27 ounces, the capacity of the smallest tumbler (Orca Chaser). I used crushed ice because it filled the tumblers more completely, leaving less room for air gaps.
We did the same test using boiling water, measuring the temperature at hour intervals over five hours. Whether it’s deciding between carbon steel and cast iron pans or between two high-end water bottles, choosing kitchen accessories can be an exhausting task. While there are a lot of similarities between the two options, there are key differences worth looking out for as a consumer. Their price points, features, and ability to keep your drink cold are all factors to keep in mind when deciding between the Owala and Stanley tumblers. Hmm, I may have to go back and grab another couple cups for Pops for Christmas so he can finally toss out all those nasty plastic fast food cups he’s been reusing. One difference I noticed is that the YETI brand specifically states dishwasher safe and Ozark Trail says to NOT place in the dishwasher.
Although the Stanley Cup was created a whopping 110 years ago, its recent craze has fans lining up to purchase, and limited ozark trail chair styles are selling out. If you didn’t want one of these cups before, Target is ensuring you’ll definitely want one this summer. Nothing came out of the Orca and Ozark Trail and only 2 small drops drained from the Yeti. The only time the tumblers were moved was during the draining process and to keep the tumblers in full sun. The 20-ounce Tervis Traveler also excelled at maintaining beverage temperature. Yet the sliding mouthpiece felt loose and flimsy, and the outer plastic coating was hard to grip, especially with wet hands.