Evenness of heating over the grill’s surface at the highest and lowest setting using all main burners plus the evenness after a 10 minute preheat, using thermocouples. I found a sweet spot after a few minutes with half power on the left burner and a trickle in the center, which seemed acceptable considering the wind. I nudged up the heat, trying to get up to a steady 325 degrees on the indirect side, but it needed constant adjustment to get anywhere weber traveler close to consistent temperature. With two of three burners going on a windy (but not that windy) day, this is a big flop. A few nights after I got the new Weber Genesis II LX grill on my roof deck, I texted my buddy Ted, proposing beer and burgers at my place. I’ve reviewed Weber’s grills before and fully expected this one, the latest addition to its line of sturdy and well-made propane grills, to stand out as a high-end weekend warrior.
They’ve been upgraded to metal, rubber tread casters, as opposed to the pair of plastic locking casters on Genesis II grills. The rubber tread guarantees smooth transport, sturdier materials improve longevity, and the push-down lock mechanism lets you secure your grill in place with minimal effort. Michael Sullivan has been a staff writer on the kitchen team at Wirecutter since 2016. Previously, he was an editor at the International Culinary Center in New York.
We favor Weber grills for their efficiency in managing multi-zone cooking, and for their generous warranties that stand out from their competition. In fact, most of the grills below have warranties beginning at 10 years for the cook box (additional parts, like gas tubes and grates, have warranties ranging from three to 10 years). We like to think of it as having one accessory weber natural gas grill for every day of the week, so grilling in the backyard never gets boring. Be aware that the Weber CRAFTED line is sold separately, and certain Weber GENESIS models require you to purchase the frame kit as well. Here, we’ll save you some work — Weber GENESIS gas grills ending in “30” or “35” include the frame kit plus a storage locker that holds flat Weber CRAFTED grillware.
Extra burner aside, it performs the same as previous Genesis models.We grilled a grate full of burger patties on the Genesis E-325s over the three main burners—leaving the fourth searing burner turned off. The burgers came off the grill with slightly paler sear marks than the ones we cooked on the Spirit II E-310, just like with the previous Genesis models we tested. It’s a very minor quibble, and one that’s moot if you use the sear zone. Many gas (that is, propane gas) grills also come in a natural-gas version, usually with a different model number that includes an “N” for natural gas. Some models have a conversion kit (as standard or optional equipment) that requires some modification to a propane grill in order to use it with natural gas.
If your return is due to an error made by us, you will not be responsible for shipping costs. All orders under $99.00 are subject to our flat rate $9.95 shipping fee, regardless of quantity or size. Flat Rate shipping applies to standard locations within the contiguous 48 states. We’ve determined that a three-burner grill is large enough for most needs, with plenty of space to cook for a family dinner or a backyard barbecue. Grills with more burners are usually overkill, and two-burner grills can feel cramped.
They also offer a less-messy cleanup due to the lack of ash. This generally means that the grill comes with a dedicated rotisserie burner the motor and spit are usually purchased separately. A dedicated rotisserie burner is usually located on the back of the firebox, slightly above the cooking grates some models use the grill’s main burner(s). This feature allows you to roast meat (a whole chicken, for example) very evenly, yielding a flavor that some people prefer to that of grilled food. The Weber iGrill 3 accessory is compatible with the Weber Genesis II, Genesis II LX and Spirit II gas grills and mounts directly into the grill.