Performance wise, the air fryer function doesn’t stack up against standalone air fryers. However, I was impressed with the bake and convection bake functions which are very speedy compared to my standard oven and do, I think, compensate for the air cuisinart air fryer oven fryer performance. The toasting was fine, but you’ll need to turn toast for best results. I used the broil (rather than convection broil) setting and added sausages to the air fry basket so that excess fat would drip out into the tray below.
However, you may still want an air fryer toaster oven for smaller cooking tasks. A toaster oven also uses less energy and generally won’t heat up your kitchen as much. If you’re looking for a combination appliance that can air fry as well as toast bread, bake treats, or roast larger quantities of food, we recommend the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro. Of all the air fryers and toaster ovens we’ve tested, it’s one of the only products that effectively combines the best of both machines. In comparison, most pod-shaped air fryers have large fans that can blast powerful streams of hot air, producing crispy food quickly. But their convection fans can’t be turned off or adjusted, so they’re not great for more delicate tasks such as baking.
All I had to do was pat them dry and lightly season them, and they came out great. Though the crumb tray and wire rack are not dishwasher-safe, the air-fryer basket and drip pan are, which is great because those are the two accessories that get dirty the quickest. When you cook something in a batter—like shrimp or onion rings—or toss in a little oil like homemade French fries, you might get messy drips on the heating elements that will need to be cleaned off.
Plus, I found myself using it for odd jobs like to quickly broil a cheese sandwich for my son or roast a small chicken when my oven was full of cake. While most air fryers have easy to clean nonstick air fry baskets, the stainless steel baskets and aluminum drip pans seen here can take some soaking and scrubbing to get spotless. We tested toaster settings just as seriously as we tested air fry functions on these combo appliances. This is a large, well-designed appliance with an LED screen and dial controls.
If the oven can’t be repaired, Breville will send you an entirely new unit. If you’re into kitchen gadgets but want to streamline and downsize, then the TOA-65 is perfect for you. If you wish you had a second oven or don’t have one at all — then it’s also your best bet.
It won’t blast food with hot air, but it can still bake relatively quickly and provide crispy results due to its small oven cavity, which is similar in size to a pod-shaped air fryer. Generally, if you opt for a convection toaster oven over an air fryer toaster cuisinart toa60 oven, you’ll pay a little less, and you’ll need to cook your food a little bit longer to get comparably crispy results. You also won’t get features like a specific “air fry” setting or basket, but those aren’t necessary to get extra-crispy results.
Additionally, we compared the cooking capacity of each model, and we took note of any egregiously noisy fans or annoying beeps. After testing, we washed all of the air fryer toaster oven components by hand to see how easy they were to clean. If you want to save counter space, spend less, or cook smaller portions of food at a time, you may still want to consider getting a pod-shaped air fryer. And if you’re looking for a regular toaster oven without a dedicated air fryer setting, we have a guide to those too. If you need extra help deciding what to buy, we walk you through more pros and cons of each machine. In my testing, the Cuisinart TOA-65 cooked most foods faster than the three other toaster-oven air fryers.